said is not dead
I hear people on the Internet, especially on YouTube, say that their English teachers had told them that “Said is dead”, meaning, don’t use the word “said” when writing a novel or short story. I don’t remember my teachers saying that specifically, but they did insist that we use more “interesting” words to describe speech. I’d never really thought too much of it until recently.
A few AuthorTubers were talking about this and saying that it’s okay to use said. In fact, they’re saying that if you do use it, it kind of floats to the background and your readers don’t really notice it. It’s almost invisible, which is a good thing. I thought that what they’re saying made sense, but it wasn’t until I picked up a book written by someone who had used anything but “said” that I realised exactly how much it changes your writing.
I found myself noticing every word they used. Replied, reciprocated, insisted, intoned, argued, countered, retorted, interjected… the list goes on. The first things I noticed was that it didn’t feel natural and it didn’t fit with the style of the writing. The next thing I noticed was that it started to really annoy me. “Said” would have been better than most of the words used.
Sure, there may be instances where you need to make sure your readers know how something was said, and that’s fine. Use another word. But “said” and “asked” are quite adequate for most things.
Although, if you write, “GET OUT OF MY HOUSE!”, you don’t need to write ‘Sarah yelled’ afterwards.
Another thing you can do so that your writing isn’t full of he said, she said: Try to use an action rather than just telling the reader that someone spoke.
For example, instead of this:
“Are you coming to the mall with me?” asked Mary.
“Um, I don’t know,” said Jill.
“We could go to that shoe shop where the cute guy works and then we could get a smoothie,” said Mary.
“Okay, I’ll get my purse!” exclaimed Jill.
Mary strode into the living room. “Are you coming to the mall with me?”
Jill cringed. She didn’t want to go, but didn’t want to upset Mary. “Um, I don’t know.”
“We could go to that shoe shop where the cute guy works,” Mary insisted as she twirled a lock of her hair around her finger, “and then we could get a smoothie.”
A devilish smile spread across Jill’s lips. “Okay, I’ll get my purse!”
Which example sounds more interesting?
On a side note, when writers say “Said Mary” instead of “Mary said”, it rubs me the wrong way. To my mind, the books I read in primary school when I was learning to read would use “Said Mary”, so it makes the writing sound childish. And it seems to sound worse when written in the present tense. Or maybe that’s just me.
Is it just me? Or does this bother you too? Let me know in the comments below. Or tell me if you think “said” is dead.
Please check out some of the helpful tutorials for authors here at TechSavvyAuthor.net.